This post was inspired -- if that's the word; I have my doubts -- by a
post by @ysabetwordsmith titled Self-Awareness Question: Boundaries. It's one of an ongoing series
of questions taken from a list of 75 Questions for Cultivating Self-Awareness on the site positively present. (The
subtitle is "positivity, awareness, self-love", if that helps.)
Specifically, the question in question is
30. Are you good at establishing boundaries?
Um...
I answered, No. To the point where I'm not even sure I understand
the concept. It seems to be related to setting limits, which I sort of
understand even though I'm very bad at it, but the way people talk about
boundaries there seems to be something else involved too.
Ysabet responded, as she does, by editing her post to include some
informative and potentially useful links (you'll find the complete set in
the notes).
The link to "What Are Personal Boundaries? How Do I Get Some?" led to a couple of
other interesting articles; probably the most (interesting? applicable?)
was "Why
Boundaries Don't Work". The bit that attracted my attention was
Setting boundaries is an advanced form of assertiveness. It
involves risk and entails taking a position about who you are, what you’re
willing to do or not do, and how you want to be treated and respected in
your relationships. It first requires awareness of your values,
feelings, and needs, plus some practice in making “I” statements
about them.
Learning assertiveness takes self-awareness and practice.
Often due to underlying shame and low self-esteem,
codependents, especially, find this difficult, because:
- They don’t know what they need or feel.
- Even when they do, they don’t value their needs, feelings, and
wants, and put others’ needs and feelings first. They feel
anxious and guilty asking for what they want or need.*
- They don’t believe that they have rights.
- They fear someone’s anger or judgment (e.g., being called selfish or
self-centered).
- They’re ashamed of being vulnerable, showing feelings
or asking for what they want and need.
- They fear losing someone’s love, friendship, or approval.
- They don’t want to be a burden.
Parts in bold are the ones I think apply in my case.
Especially that first item: "They don’t know what they need or
feel." I've mentioned alexithymia in a few times
before. Parts in italics are prerequisites that I'm missing:
assertiveness, self-awareness, and self-esteem.
Quite a lot of that list doesn't seem to apply to me. I'm not a
codependent (as far as I can tell). I don't feel as though other people
are judging me. Judging myself? Yeah, there's a lot of that,
based on decades of bad decisions. I put others' needs above my own
because I'm Colleen's main caregiver. Only caregiver, given the
pandemic. Some of it, like the bit about rights, I'm not sure I
understand in this context.
*The second point needs to be deconstructed, because it's way
too complicated to be summed up in a sentence. It may even need a whole
other post, but I think I can at least make a start. My comments in
parentheses; brackets are used for interpolation, and braces are used for
grouping because English isn't associative.
Even when they do [know what they need or feel which of course I
usually don't],
they don’t {value I'm no good at assigning values to variables I
don't know how to measure}
their {needs, feelings these taken together seem to be referring
specifically to emotional needs? See alexithymia.},
and {wants choice paralysis is a thing, but more of the time I
have extreme problems trying to identify something I want. Asking me what
I want for my birthday is going to get you half a minute of blank stare.
Other times I know of things I want, but they're impossible. I never got
a pony, either.},
and put {others’ needs and feelings first What happened to
"wants"? This needs some unpacking. 1. If somebody tells me what they
need, I know what to do; if I have to guess, it's a lot harder, though I'm
getting better at it. 2. I'm a caregiver. If the person I'm caring for
needs something, it's usually urgent. Or I have to assume it's urgent
unless told otherwise. 3. People rarely tell me what they're feeling. I
can sometimes tell something is wrong, but I can't always tell what.
4. Even if they do tell me, I'm not very good at figuring out what to do
about it. 5. I appear to be some kind of empath -- don't ask me how that
jibes with alexithymia. If somebody is hurting, it hurts me as well, and
more when it's about something I can't fix. Sympathy only goes so far.
And if my distress bleeds over into theirs, we have a classic positive
feedback loop.}.
They {feel anxious and guilty asking for what they want or need I
have a lot of trouble asking for help of any kind, but I have no idea what
emotions are involved in that.}.
I suspect that this is going to be at least as confusing for anyone
reading this as it is for me. Sorry about that. I'm probably making this
a lot more complicated than it needs to be. Also, it sounds a lot like
making excuses.
Maybe part of my problem with boundaries is that I can't tell whether I
have a problem with boundaries. If that makes sense. For all I know I
have (some) boundaries, but just don't notice them or know how to think
about them.
Detecting other people's boundaries is a different problem
altogether, and might not even be all that closely related. It's a
different set of skills, in any case. I'm not claiming to be any good at
that, either, and that is a problem. However, I can compensate
most of the time by making conservative assumptions. It's similar to the
way I try to handle left turns and other situations when I'm driving,
compensating for what I know is unreliable judgement and a very limited
ability to estimate speeds and distances. And similar in what happens
when I fail to see a warning sign in a place I'm not expecting one, or get
impatient. At least cars aren't usually invisible. (That doesn't always
mean that I see them, though. That's how I totaled the Honda.)
( links )
I thought I'd have more to say on this topic, but it's all slipped away.
Or got shoved down another rabbit hole. Maybe later.